0204 579 8270

Canterbury & Kent

Saromi v Bell (2026) UKUT 403 (LC): Kent Restrictive Covenant Discharged for £10,000 After Neighbours Claimed £20,000 With No Valuation Evidence, What Kent Owners and Surveyors Should Know (November 2026)

A derelict chapel in a Kent village lane, a covenant from 1950 and a neighbour’s garden: the facts of Saromi v Bell (2026) UKUT 403 (LC) will be familiar to anyone who deals with infill plots in the county. On 21 October 2026 the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) discharged a covenant that restricted the building to use as a place of worship, clearing the way for a new house. The neighbours had asked for £20,000 in compensation. They were awarded £10,000.

The gap between those two figures is the practical lesson. The neighbours put in no valuation evidence at all, and the Tribunal had to fix the sum on its own judgment.

The site and the covenant

The application land is the former Gospel Church at 1A Alfan Lane, Wilmington, near Dartford. It is a plot of about 545 square metres holding a dilapidated single-storey church that has been unoccupied since 2008. The applicants bought it on 3 August 2021.

The plot was once part of the rear garden of a house on Birchwood Road. A conveyance dated 19 September 1950 restricted the building on it to use as a place of worship. The objectors have lived in the Birchwood Road house for more than 28 years, and their garden adjoins the site.

Planning took time. Two applications were refused in 2022. Permission in Principle was granted on 7 March 2025, and Technical Details Consent followed on 20 January 2026 for a one-and-a-half-storey, four-bedroom house with a gross internal floor area of 278.6 square metres, including a basement pool and gym. The house would sit at the end of the plot nearest the objectors’ garden boundary.

With planning in place, the covenant was the remaining obstacle. The applicants applied under section 84 of the Law of Property Act 1925 to have it discharged or modified.

What the Tribunal decided

The case was decided on written representations by Mrs Diane Martin TD MRICS FAAV, who inspected the site on 15 September 2026. By then the objectors had accepted that the covenant should be modified in principle. What remained was the legal basis and the money.

Ground (a): the covenant was not obsolete

The applicants’ first argument was that the covenant was obsolete. That failed. The Tribunal held that a restriction is not obsolete simply because worship has stopped, demand for a chapel has gone or the neighbourhood has changed. The covenant was negative in effect and could still protect the neighbouring house from residential development in what had been its back garden.

The planning permission did not settle the point. A council’s decision reflects planning policy and is not decisive on whether a private covenant still has a purpose.

Ground (aa): reasonable use impeded, limited benefit

The applicants succeeded on ground (aa). The objectors accepted that building a house was a reasonable use of the land and that the covenant impeded it. The question was whether the covenant gave them a practical benefit of substantial value or advantage.

The Tribunal compared the proposed house with a hypothetical church in active use, not with the quiet vacant site the neighbours had been used to since 2008. The covenant did not limit the height, footprint or position of any replacement church. On that basis the benefit it secured was described as limited but not substantial.

Ground (c): some injury, so no discharge without payment

The argument that the neighbours would suffer no injury at all failed. The Tribunal accepted that there would be some loss of privacy and outlook, particularly to a secluded part of the garden close to the new building.

The compensation: £20,000 claimed, £10,000 awarded

The objectors said the development would harm their privacy and outlook and claimed £20,000. They also raised a possible loss in value of their home as a future concern.

The Tribunal recorded that they had produced no evidence of the current value of their house and nothing to support the £20,000 figure. It noted that their large garden had other sitting areas and concluded that market value was unlikely to be affected. It accepted that there would be a modest personal loss and assessed compensation at £10,000, drawing on its own experience as an expert tribunal.

The covenant is discharged only if the applicants show within four months that the £10,000 has been paid and received. No costs order was made, which is usual for cases decided on written representations.

Why valuation evidence matters in covenant disputes

Compensation under section 84 is meant to make up for loss or disadvantage suffered because of the discharge or modification. That calls for evidence. In a case like this, a chartered surveyor’s report would usually address:

  • the market value of the neighbouring property as it stands with the benefit of the covenant;
  • its value with the covenant discharged and the permitted development built;
  • comparable sales that show how the market treats overlooking, loss of outlook or proximity to new building;
  • any factors that reduce the effect, such as obscured glazing, screening or the size and layout of the garden.

Without that analysis, a tribunal can only make a broad assessment. That may work for or against either side. Here the objectors recovered half of what they asked for. An applicant who offers nothing and puts in no evidence takes the same risk in reverse.

There is a point for applicants too. The applicants argued that any loss in value was speculative, and the Tribunal agreed that market value was unlikely to be affected. A short valuation report addressing the issue directly would have put that argument on firmer ground.

What Kent owners and developers should take from it

Check the title early. Many Kent infill plots, former chapels, halls and garden land carry covenants from the first half of the twentieth century. Planning permission does not remove them.

Do not rely on obsolescence. A covenant can outlive the use it was written for if it still protects a neighbour.

The comparison is with lawful use, not with dereliction. A neighbour who has enjoyed a silent empty building for years cannot treat that as the baseline.

Expect to pay something where there is real impact. Ground (aa) allows a covenant to go where money is adequate compensation. The question becomes how much.

Bring evidence. For objectors and applicants alike, a proportionate valuation report is the difference between a figure that is argued and a figure that is proved.

How Canterbury Surveyors can help

We provide Red Book valuations and expert reports across Kent for restrictive covenant applications, boundary and neighbour disputes and development sites. If a covenant stands between you and a planning permission, or a neighbour’s application threatens your property, we can advise on the likely effect on value and the evidence a tribunal will expect.

Frequently asked questions

What did the Upper Tribunal decide in Saromi v Bell?

On 21 October 2026 it discharged a 1950 covenant restricting a former church at Wilmington, near Dartford, to use as a place of worship, on condition that the applicants pay the neighbouring owners £10,000.

Why did the neighbours not receive the £20,000 they claimed?

They provided no valuation evidence and nothing to support the figure. The Tribunal found that market value was unlikely to be affected and assessed a modest personal loss at £10,000.

Does planning permission override a restrictive covenant?

No. Planning permission and private covenants are separate. A covenant remains enforceable until it is released by agreement or discharged or modified by the Upper Tribunal.

Is a valuation report needed for a section 84 application?

It is not compulsory, but where compensation or loss of value is in issue it is usually the only reliable way to prove or resist a figure.

This article is a general summary of a published decision for information only. It is not legal or valuation advice.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top