0204 579 8270

Canterbury & Kent

Egan v Morgan (2026) EWHC 2946 (BP): Boundary Dispute Costs Over £1m Claimed on a 45 sq m Strip, No Costs Order, Lessons for Kent Owners (November 2026)

About 45 square metres of grass, scrub and trees. Ten years of litigation. More than £1 million in legal fees claimed by one side alone. On 16 November 2026 the High Court handed down Egan v Morgan (2026) EWHC 2946 (BP), an appeal from the County Court at Maidstone about boundary dispute costs, and dismissed it. The result is that the earlier order stands: subject to limited exceptions, there is no order as to the costs of the proceedings, so each side carries its own bill [1].

For anyone in Kent arguing with a neighbour over a hedge or a fence line, the judgment shows how a court decides who “won” a boundary case and why winning some damages does not mean recovering costs.

Key takeaways

  • The decision: Mr Justice Tappin dismissed Mary Egan’s appeal on 16 November 2026 and left in place the trial judge’s order of no order as to costs [1].
  • The scale: the dispute was about roughly 45 square metres along a boundary of about 60 metres. The appellant claims to have spent over £1 million and the respondents a six-figure sum [1].
  • The outcome at trial: the judge fixed the boundary on a line that neither side had argued for, so he treated the result as “something of a score-draw” [1].
  • The damages: the appellant was awarded £1,300, a further £1,300 in aggravated damages and £3,250 in lieu of an injunction, yet still recovered no costs [1].

What happened in Egan v Morgan?

The High Court judgment summarises the trial judgment of Recorder Dagnall dated 9 August 2022 [1]. In the area of the boundary between two neighbouring properties there was a hedge. To the west was the garden of Neil and Fiona Morgan. To the east was a field owned by Mary Egan. East of the hedge stood an old fence, which the trial judge called Fence 1.

In 2015 the Morgans went into the field and put up wooden posts slightly to the east of Fence 1. After complaints they built Fence 2, with wooden posts, and took Fence 1 down. Ms Egan then removed Fence 2. The Morgans went back into the field and built Fence 3, with concrete posts, on or slightly to the west of the line of Fence 2 [1].

The court case began with the Morgans claiming damages for the removal of Fence 2. Ms Egan counterclaimed. Her main case was that the legal boundary ran through the middle of the hedge. Her fallback was that the boundary was Fence 1 and that she owned the land between Fence 1 and the hedge by adverse possession. She asked for a declaration, an injunction to remove Fence 3, and damages for trespass [1].

The surprise witness and “Fence 0”

At trial a witness, Mr Brooks, gave evidence that seems to have surprised both parties. He said there had once been an earlier fence, a few inches west of Fence 1 but still east of the hedge. The judge called it Fence 0 and held that Fence 0 had been the boundary [1].

On the trial judge’s findings:

  • a limited part of Fence 3 lay east of the true boundary, by a matter of a few inches;
  • the majority of Fence 2 had also been on the wrong side;
  • the Morgans had trespassed by going onto Ms Egan’s land to put up posts and fences and to remove Fence 1 [1].

Ms Egan was awarded £1,300 in damages and £1,300 in aggravated damages for trespass. The Morgans’ own damages claim failed. But the judge refused to order Fence 3 to be removed. He awarded £3,250 in damages in lieu of an injunction and declared that the boundary should from then on be the line of Fence 3 [1]. Those three awards add up to £5,850.

How did the court deal with the boundary dispute costs?

The timeline below is taken from the judgment [1].

Date Event
2016 Litigation begins
9 August 2022 Trial judgment (88 pages)
6 November 2024 Consequentials judgment on costs (38 pages)
4 March 2025 Order: no order as to costs, subject to limited exceptions
28 July 2025 Permission to appeal granted on limited grounds
12 November 2026 Appeal hearing
16 November 2026 Appeal dismissed

One of those exceptions was that the Morgans had to pay one third of Ms Egan’s costs of attending a hearing on 23 November 2017 [1].

Under the Civil Procedure Rules the general rule is that the unsuccessful party pays the successful party’s costs, but the court may make a different order. It looks at all the circumstances, including the parties’ conduct and whether a party has succeeded on part of its case [2].

The trial judge decided there was no successful party. In his words, the outcome was “something of a ‘score-draw'”. The Morgans had done better on where the boundary was. Ms Egan had done better on remedies, damages and findings about past wrongdoing [1].

Why did the High Court dismiss the appeal?

Mr Justice Tappin rejected each of the grounds on which Ms Egan had permission to appeal [1].

Ground 1: who was the successful party?

Ms Egan argued that she was the winner because she received damages and the Morgans did not. She said the Morgans were the ones “writing the cheque”.

The High Court disagreed. Three points stand out:

  1. Non-money outcomes count. It was not right to look only at the financial remedies and ignore the fact that Ms Egan failed to get the declaration and the injunction she asked for.
  2. Her core case failed. The claim that the boundary ran through the middle of the hedge was the core of her pleaded case, and she kept to it even after the Fence 0 evidence came out. The trial judge had called the location of the boundary the most important point of all.
  3. Fence 3 stayed. She had strongly pressed for its removal. The ruling that Fence 3 would become the boundary was of real value to the Morgans.

The trial judge had to ask “who, as a matter of substance and reality, has won”. It was not possible for an appeal court to say he was wrong to find there was no overall winner [1].

Grounds 2A and 2B: conduct

Ms Egan also relied on the way the litigation had been run. The trial judge had described abusive language used by Mr Morgan towards the other side’s lawyers, towards judges and towards court staff as something to be deplored. Mr Justice Tappin agreed that such behaviour is “deplorable and unacceptable” [1].

Even so, the appeal failed. Conduct mainly matters for costs because of its effect in increasing costs, although very serious misconduct can attract a proportionate costs penalty on its own. The trial judge had applied that test and had already marked the behaviour at the 2017 hearing with a specific costs order. How much weight to give the rest was a matter for him [1].

Why do boundary dispute costs so often outrun the value of the land?

The judgment records the trial judge’s remark that boundary disputes are often said to cause time, cost and energy “wholly out of proportion to the financial value of the area of land in dispute”. Mr Justice Tappin added: “That is certainly true of this dispute.” [1]

The general boundaries rule adds to the difficulty. HM Land Registry’s guidance confirms that the boundary of a registered estate shown on the register is a general boundary. The red line on a title plan does not fix the exact legal line [3]. See also this guide to boundary dispute resolution and expert witness strategies for UK property owners.

What does the case say about expert evidence from boundary surveyors?

The appeal judgment is about costs. It does not describe what expert surveying evidence, if any, was given at trial, and this article does not guess. What it does show is the kind of evidence that decided the boundary: a witness’s account of where an earlier fence had stood [1]. That is a useful prompt for anyone instructing a surveyor as an expert.

The rules on expert evidence. In court proceedings, expert evidence is restricted to what is reasonably required to resolve the case, and no party may rely on an expert’s report without the court’s permission. The expert’s duty is to help the court, and that duty overrides any obligation to the person who instructs or pays them [4].

Single joint experts and expert discussions. Where both sides want expert evidence on an issue, the court may direct that it is given by a single joint expert. It may also direct the experts to meet, identify the issues and reach an agreed opinion where possible, then set out in a statement what they agree and disagree on [4]. In a dispute over inches, a jointly instructed measured survey is one way to narrow the argument.

Measured surveys and old features. For a determined boundary application, HM Land Registry asks for a plan drawn to a stated scale, preferably no smaller than 1:200, with measurements accurate to +/-10mm [3]. But precision about the present does not answer the legal question, which often turns on where features stood in the past. In this case the decisive line was an earlier fence that neither party had pleaded [1]. Historical evidence, such as old photographs and earlier plans, is best gathered early and tested against the survey.

Related reading on this site covers RICS evidence standards for expert witness valuations in stabilising markets and expert witness roles in residential disputes and the RICS guidelines for sales and valuation conflicts.

What does this mean for homeowners and landowners in Kent?

The case was tried in the County Court at Maidstone [1]. The judgment does not give the address of the land. The lessons, though, apply to any garden or field boundary in Canterbury and across Kent.

  • Do not move or remove fences while a line is disputed. In this case the trespass findings and the aggravated damages came from going onto the neighbour’s land to put up posts and fences [1].
  • Consider agreeing the line. HM Land Registry’s guidance says a boundary agreement need not be in writing to be enforceable, but that it is obviously sensible to put it in writing. The same guidance covers applications for a determined boundary [3].
  • Think about costs from day one. A court looks at who won in substance, at conduct and at admissible offers to settle [2].

Frequently asked questions

What was decided in Egan v Morgan?

On 16 November 2026 Mr Justice Tappin dismissed an appeal against a costs order made in the County Court at Maidstone. The order of no order as to costs, subject to limited exceptions, remains in place [1].

Why did the party who won damages not recover her costs?

Because the trial judge found that neither side was the successful party overall. The appellant won damages, but lost her main case on where the boundary was and was refused an injunction. The High Court held that the judge was entitled to weigh those non-money outcomes [1].

Does bad behaviour in litigation always lead to a costs penalty?

No. Conduct is mainly relevant because of its effect in increasing costs. Very serious misconduct can be penalised regardless, but the penalty should be proportionate [1].

Is the Land Registry title plan enough to prove where a boundary is?

Usually not. The boundary shown on the register is a general boundary, so the plan does not fix the exact legal line unless the boundary has been formally determined [3].

Will the court allow each side to have its own surveyor as an expert?

Not automatically. The court’s permission is needed for expert evidence, it is limited to what is reasonably required, and the court may direct a single joint expert instead [4].

Conclusion

Egan v Morgan is a costs appeal, not a ruling on how to find a boundary, but its message is plain. After a decade of litigation over about 45 square metres, the boundary was fixed on the line of a fence already in place, the damages totalled £5,850, and neither side recovered the general costs of the proceedings. Practical next steps: leave the fences alone, gather the historical evidence, obtain an impartial measured survey, take legal advice and make a realistic offer to settle before positions harden.

This article is general information only and is not legal advice. Anyone involved in a boundary dispute should take advice from a solicitor on their own facts.

References

  1. Mary Egan v Neil Morgan & Anor (2026) EWHC 2946 (BP), High Court, Mr Justice Tappin, 16 November 2026. caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.
  2. Civil Procedure Rules, Part 44 (General Rules About Costs), rule 44.2. justice.gov.uk.
  3. HM Land Registry, Practice Guide 40, Supplement 4: Boundary agreements and determined boundaries (updated 1 June 2026). gov.uk.
  4. Civil Procedure Rules, Part 35 (Experts and Assessors). justice.gov.uk.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top