0204 579 8270

Canterbury & Kent

Boyd v Donaghey (2026) UKFTT 1520 (PC): How a Chesterfield Field Was Won by Adverse Possession Despite a Claimed Rental Agreement, and the Boundary and Evidence Lessons for Kent Landowners and Surveyors (November 2026)

Ten years of cattle, a locked gate and a fence that HM Land Registry’s own surveyor mapped were enough to transfer part of a Derbyshire field from a registered owner’s estate to the man who had been grazing it. On 29 October 2026 the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) directed the Chief Land Registrar to give effect to Mr Ian Boyd’s application in Boyd v Donaghey (2026) UKFTT 1520 (PC) [1]. The decision is a clear illustration of adverse possession registered land ten years evidence requirements under Schedule 6 to the Land Registration Act 2002, and of why a claimed rental agreement is only a defence if the owner can prove it.

For Kent landowners the case is a useful warning in both directions. This article is general information, not legal advice.

Key Takeaways

  • For registered land, an applicant must show ten years’ adverse possession ending on the date of the application; here the relevant period was 8 July 2014 to 8 July 2024 [1][2].
  • HM Land Registry carried out its own survey on receipt of the application and mapped a fence south of the river; the application proceeded only for the land within that fence [1].
  • The owners’ argument that use was by permission under a rental agreement failed because they could not prove the agreement lasted beyond the end of 2013, and permission given to a third party was not permission to the applicant [1].
  • Daily attendance, cattle, fence maintenance and a locked gate were the acts of possession the Tribunal accepted [1].
  • The case shows how measured surveys, fence lines and dated evidence decide these disputes, and why Kent landowners should inspect and record what is happening on their land.

The dispute: a field by the River Rothay at Lower Pilsley

Field 2 lies on the north side of Pilsley Road at Lower Pilsley, near Chesterfield, bounded by the River Rothay, the railway and the road, and was registered under title DY405312 in the name of the late Julie Wright. Her personal representatives, Andrew Donaghey and Emma Cusack, objected to Mr Boyd’s claim. The neighbouring owners of Fields 1 and 3 and Mill Cottage, Mr and Mrs Pollard, had also objected but were barred as parties for failing to provide a statement of case; they gave evidence for the first respondents instead [1].

Judge Laura D’Cruz heard the case at Derby Justice Centre on 2, 3 and 4 September 2026 [1].

Adverse possession registered land ten years evidence: the Schedule 6 test

For registered land, paragraph 1 of Schedule 6 to the Land Registration Act 2002 allows a person to apply to be registered as proprietor if they have been in adverse possession for ten years ending on the date of the application [2]. If the registered proprietor serves a counter-notice, the applicant must also satisfy one of three further conditions in paragraph 5 [2]. For unregistered land the position is different: twelve years’ possession is needed under the Limitation Act 1980.

Mr Boyd’s application was made in form ADV1 dated 18 June 2024 and received by HM Land Registry on 8 July 2024, so the Tribunal had to decide whether he was in adverse possession throughout 8 July 2014 to 8 July 2024, described in the decision as ‘the Relevant Period’ [1].

The Tribunal applied the familiar principles from Powell v McFarlane and J A Pye (Oxford) Ltd v Graham: factual possession, meaning exclusive physical control judged by the nature of the land, and an intention to possess. Under Buckinghamshire County Council v Moran, possession under a licence from the paper owner is never adverse [1]. Mr Boyd had to prove possession; the respondents had to prove permission [1].

The HM Land Registry survey and why only part of the field was in play

On receiving the application, HM Land Registry carried out a survey which identified and mapped a fence south of the river. The Registry was not satisfied that Mr Boyd could show possession beyond that fence, so the application proceeded only for the land within it, given the provisional title number DY582696 and called ‘the Disputed Land’ [1].

The evidence of possession: cattle, fences, a locked gate and daily attendance

Mr Boyd’s late brother Stuart bought Mill Cottage in 2001 and further land in 2006, and installed bridges over the river to Field 2. Mr Steve Wright, Julie’s husband, bought Field 2 in 2006 as a wildlife area; it was transferred into Julie’s name in 2014. Stuart moved to Thailand in 2013 and died in 2019 [1].

From March 2013 Mr Boyd rented Mill Cottage from Stuart to run a community care farm, later known as the Chesterfield Community Care Farm, and offices. His case was that from then on he used Field 2 for his own cattle, which had previously been Stuart’s, with rotational grazing. He said he attended almost every day, maintained the fences, kept the gate locked and allowed no one else on the land without his permission [1].

In spring 2020 he left Mill Cottage, moving cabins onto Field 2. After the Pollards bought Mill Cottage in autumn 2020 and removed a partial fence and the bridges, Mr Boyd fenced the northern boundary of the Disputed Land [1]. His sons and former employees supported his account [1].

The permission argument: why a claimed rental agreement did not defeat the claim

The respondents’ answer was that any possession was by permission. Mr Wright said that from 2008 Stuart rented Field 2 from April to December each year, extended annually with rent paid in advance, with the last rent paid in December 2016, and that he left notices to quit in 2019 [1].

The Tribunal found that the respondents had not shown the rental agreement lasted beyond the end of 2013. There was no convincing evidence of rent payments after that date, and the agreement only extended on payment of rent in advance, so without payment it did not roll forward [1].

Even if the agreement had continued, the judge held that permission given to Stuart would not amount to permission to Mr Boyd unless the respondents also showed that Mr Boyd was on the land with Stuart’s permission, which they did not [1]. Possession was therefore adverse throughout the Relevant Period [1].

A licence is a complete answer to adverse possession, but only if the owner can prove it existed, continued, and covered the person actually in possession.

What the Tribunal decided and what happens next

The Tribunal directed the Chief Land Registrar to give effect to Mr Boyd’s original application as if the objections had not been made; any costs application was to be made by 26 November 2026 [1].

Boundary and land registration lessons for Kent landowners

Across Kent, paddocks, orchards and village plots are often used rather than owned, and Boyd v Donaghey points to practical lessons on both sides of the fence.

If you own land someone else is using: put any permission in writing and renew it, because an arrangement that lapses when rent stops can leave the occupier’s possession adverse [1]; know who is actually on the land, since permission to one person is not permission to their successor [1]; and respond promptly to any HM Land Registry notice, as a counter-notice triggers the additional Schedule 6 conditions [2].

If you have used land for years without title: enclosure, a locked gate and exclusive use are the strongest evidence, so keep records of fencing work and animal movements, and be ready to prove the whole ten-year period.

For an overview of how these disputes are run and resolved, see Boundary Dispute Resolution In 2026 Expert Witness Strategies For Uk Property Owners.

Expert evidence: how a chartered surveyor’s survey, fence-line plans and dated photographs decide these cases

In Boyd v Donaghey the physical extent of the claim was fixed by HM Land Registry’s own survey of the fence line [1]. A chartered surveyor acting as an expert witness adds the same discipline to a party’s case:

  1. A measured survey plotting fences, gates, hedges and watercourses against the title plan.
  2. A chronology of physical features, using dated photographs, aerial imagery and site observation to show when fences and gates appeared or changed.
  3. Comparison with the registered extent, explaining the general boundaries rule.
  4. An impartial report that carries weight against witness recollection that may be mistaken or self-serving.

Preparing evidence to that standard is discussed in Expert Witness Preparation For Homebuying Reform Challenges Evidence Standards In Early 2026 Implementation.

What to do if someone is using your land in Kent

Check the title plan against the ground, commission a measured boundary survey if they differ, gather dated evidence such as photographs, fencing invoices and grazing agreements, and take legal advice before serving or responding to any notice; HM Land Registry’s practice guide explains the procedure [3].

How Canterbury Surveyors can help

Canterbury Surveyors is an RICS practice serving Canterbury, Whitstable, Herne Bay, Faversham, Ashford and east Kent, preparing measured boundary surveys, boundary dispute reports and expert witness evidence alongside building surveys and valuations.

FAQ

How long is adverse possession of registered land?

Ten years ending on the date of the application under paragraph 1 of Schedule 6 to the Land Registration Act 2002, with further conditions if the registered proprietor serves a counter-notice [2]. Unregistered land requires twelve years.

Does a rental agreement always defeat adverse possession?

Possession under a licence or tenancy is not adverse, but the owner must prove the arrangement existed and continued. In Boyd v Donaghey the owners could not show the agreement lasted beyond 2013, and permission to one person did not extend to another [1].

What evidence did the applicant rely on?

His own account of grazing cattle, near-daily attendance, fence maintenance and a locked gate, supported by his sons and former employees [1].

Why did HM Land Registry reduce the land claimed?

Its survey mapped a fence south of the river and it was not satisfied the applicant possessed the land beyond it, so the application proceeded only for the enclosed part [1].

Conclusion

Boyd v Donaghey (2026) UKFTT 1520 (PC) is a reminder that adverse possession registered land ten years evidence turns on two things: what the applicant actually did on the land for the whole period, and whether the owner can prove permission. Cattle, fences, a locked gate and daily attendance carried the applicant; an unproven rental agreement that stopped at the end of 2013 sank the objection [1]. The physical fence line, mapped by HM Land Registry, defined the prize. Kent landowners should check their titles against the ground, document any permissions in writing, and obtain a measured survey and professional evidence as soon as a question over use arises.

References

  1. Boyd v Donaghey and others (2026) UKFTT 1520 (PC), First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber), decision of 29 October 2026, Find Case Law, The National Archives. caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.
  2. Land Registration Act 2002, Schedule 6. legislation.gov.uk.
  3. HM Land Registry, Practice guide 4: adverse possession of registered land. gov.uk.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top