Canterbury & Kent
Kingdom Hall Trust v Davies (2026) EWCA Civ 1377: Court of Appeal Blocks a Prescriptive Right of Way Over Charity Land, What Kent Buyers, Surveyors and Boundary Experts Should Check in November 2026
Forty-three years of open, uninterrupted use. Two tribunals in the claimant’s favour. Then the Court of Appeal said the right of way never existed, because for the whole of that period nobody owned the land who could lawfully have granted it. Kingdom Hall Trust v Davies, handed down on 2 November 2026, changes how every prescriptive right of way surveyor and boundary expert should approach access claims over land held by charities, churches and trusts [1].
Key Takeaways
- A prescriptive right of way under the doctrine of lost modern grant cannot be presumed where there was no competent grantor throughout the period of use.
- The Court of Appeal held that the widely cited statement in Tehidy Minerals relied on by both tribunals was obiter and too broadly expressed.
- The ruling turned on title history: who owned the servient land, from when, and in what legal capacity.
- Buyers relying on long-used access across charity-owned land, common in Kent villages, need title investigation as well as evidence of use.
- Surveyors assembling rights-of-way evidence should now report ownership history alongside plans, measurements and photographs.
The facts
Peter Davies claimed pedestrian and vehicular rights over a car park behind the Telford Kingdom Hall for his property, Pleasington, on Plough Road, Telford. The Kingdom Hall site, then a cinema, and Pleasington had been in common freehold ownership until 10 February 1958, when Pleasington was sold off [1].
On 17 July 1967 the freehold of the Kingdom Hall passed to four trustees of the Telford Oakengates Congregation, who held it on charitable trusts. On 29 May 1997 it passed to the Kingdom Hall Trust Co, and after a 2020 merger that company became the sole legal owner [1].
The First-tier Tribunal, Judge Paton, found open use of the car park “as of right” from 24 August 1977 to 11 February 2021 and rejected claims of earlier use. The parties accepted that section 29 of the Charities Act 1960 restricted disposals of charity land without a court order or Charity Commission consent, and that this restriction covered the grant of an easement. There was therefore no competent grantor after 17 July 1967 [1].
Both the First-tier Tribunal and the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber), in a decision reported as (2025) UKUT 294 (LC), presumed a lost grant made between 1958 and 1967, roughly ten years before the proven use began [1].
What the Court of Appeal decided
Lewison LJ gave the lead judgment, with which Males LJ and Miles LJ agreed. The only mention of a chartered surveyor appears in the court’s summary of the statutory regime, where the Charities Act 1992 permitted certain disposals if trustees obtained a surveyor’s advice, advertised the disposal and were satisfied it was in the charity’s best interests. No expert evidence is described in the judgment [1].
Use alone, however long and however open, cannot create a right that the landowner had no power to grant.
Why this matters in Canterbury and across Kent
East Kent has an unusually high proportion of land held by ecclesiastical bodies, charitable trusts, almshouse foundations and village hall committees. Farm tracks, rear access to cottages, shared yards behind chapels and routes across recreation grounds are often used for decades without any written grant.
Before this ruling, a buyer or seller could point to twenty years of use and expect a prescriptive right to be recognised. After it, the question is also who owned the land during those twenty years and whether that owner could lawfully have granted the easement.
For buyers of Kent property relying on informal access
- Ask the conveyancer to investigate the title to the land crossed, not just the land being bought.
- If the servient land is or was held on charitable trusts, treat any prescriptive claim as doubtful until advised otherwise.
- Consider negotiating an express easement, with Charity Commission consent where required, before exchange.
For sellers and lenders
A right of way that cannot be established affects marketability and mortgage valuation. Red Book valuers and lenders will want to see either a registered easement or clear title evidence supporting prescription.
What a prescriptive right of way surveyor should now do
Surveyors are routinely instructed to assemble evidence of long use. Kingdom Hall Trust v Davies does not reduce that role; it extends it.
Traditional evidence of use
- Measured survey of the route, width and surface, tied to Ordnance Survey and title plans.
- Historic mapping and dated aerial photography showing the track or hardstanding over time.
- Dated photographs, witness statements and records of maintenance.
- Analysis of gates, locks, signs or interruptions that might defeat “as of right” use.
Added after this ruling
- A chronology of ownership of the servient land, drawn from the registered title and pre-registration deeds.
- Identification of any period when the owner was a charity, a body subject to statutory restrictions on disposal, or otherwise unable to grant an easement.
- Cross-referencing the user period against the ownership chronology, so the solicitor can see at a glance whether a competent grantor existed throughout.
Expert evidence in rights-of-way disputes
Prescriptive rights of way are decided in the Property Chamber of the First-tier Tribunal, the Lands Chamber and the courts. Where a surveyor gives opinion evidence, the discipline is the same as under CPR Part 35 and Practice Direction 35: a clear statement of instructions, the documents and site data relied on, a separation of measured fact from opinion, and a statement of truth. The RICS professional standard Surveyors acting as expert witnesses, 5th edition, takes effect on 30 November 2026 and applies to chartered surveyors in all of these forums.
Surveyors should be careful about the limits of their expertise. Whether a particular owner was a competent grantor is a legal question for the advocate and the tribunal. The surveyor’s contribution is accurate factual material, clearly presented, on which that legal argument can be built.
What this means for Kent homeowners and buyers
- Do not assume that long use of a track or yard gives you a right over it. The owner’s legal capacity during the user period now matters as much as the use itself.
- If access to your home crosses church, chapel, charity or trust land, ask for a title investigation and consider an express grant.
- Keep dated evidence of your own use in case a claim must be made or defended.
What this means for surveyors and solicitors
- Instructions for rights-of-way evidence should include an ownership chronology of the servient land.
- Level 2 and Level 3 survey reports and Red Book valuations should flag access that depends on unregistered or prescriptive rights, particularly over charity land.
- Solicitors should review live prescriptive claims against the competent-grantor requirement and advise clients on the point the Court of Appeal left open.
Conclusion
Kingdom Hall Trust v Davies narrows the doctrine of lost modern grant in a way that will be felt most in rural and village Kent, where access across charity and church land is commonplace. The prescriptive right of way surveyor now has a two-part task: prove the use, and document who owned the land while that use took place. The judgment is published on the National Archives Find Case Law service [1].
References
- The Kingdom Hall Trust v Peter Robert Davies (2026) EWCA Civ 1377, Court of Appeal (Civil Division), Lewison, Males and Miles LJJ, 2 November 2026. caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.
Related services from Canterbury Surveyors
- Boundary surveys
- Building expert witness surveyors
- RICS property valuations
- RICS Homebuyer Surveys (Level 2)
Get a fixed-fee quote or call 0204 579 8270.
